Why does my competitor outrank my pool company in Google Maps?

For pool builders who keep seeing the same competitor above them in Maps: how to work out which of Google’s ranking factors explains the gap, and which gaps you can close.

Get a free visibility audit · Book a growth call

Why does another pool builder show up above me in the Google map pack?

Usually because Google sees them as a closer, more relevant or better-known match for that search: Google says local results are mainly based on relevance, distance and popularity, and nobody can pay for a better local ranking. Check first whether the listing above you is an ad, then whether their office is closer to where the search happened, whether their category and services match the search better, and whether they have more reviews and more websites linking to them. Some gaps, like distance, you can’t close in Maps; others, like reviews and a thin profile, you can.

Finding the gap between your profile and the builder above you is where our local SEO work starts, and it’s part of how we approach Maps on our pool builder marketing page. For the full setup rather than a diagnosis, browse the pool builder marketing questions library.

Why does Google put another pool builder above me?

Google says local results are mainly based on three things. Relevance is how well a profile matches what someone searched. Distance is how far each business is from the searcher, or from where Google thinks they are. Prominence, which Google’s summary calls popularity, is how well known a business is, based partly on how many websites link to it and how many reviews it has; more reviews and positive ratings can help. Source: Tips to improve your local ranking on Google.

Google also says there’s no way to request or pay for a better local ranking, and that it keeps the details of the algorithm confidential. So nobody can tell you exactly why one builder sits above another; what you can do is compare the two profiles on each factor Google names. If you’d rather start with the full setup, read ranking a pool company in Maps.

Is the competitor above me actually paying for that spot?

Check this first, because it changes everything else. Google says ads are always labeled “Sponsored” or “Ad” and shown separately from search results, and that nobody can pay for special treatment in how its algorithms rank results. Source: Automatically generating and ranking results. Google Ads also lets advertisers attach location assets, and Google says those locations can appear beside, above or below search results on Google Maps, including the Maps app. Source: About location assets.

So if the builder above you carries an ad label, you’re not being outranked; you’re being outbid. That’s a budget decision, not a profile problem, and copying their profile won’t move you past an ad. Look at the first organic listing below the ads to see where you really stand.

Am I seeing the same map my customers see?

Probably not. Because distance is one of the three factors, and Google uses what it knows about the searcher’s location when they don’t share it, the map you see from your office is shaped by your office. Source: Tips to improve your local ranking on Google. A competitor based across town will look stronger from their side of town and weaker from yours.

Before you change anything, find out where the gap really is. Ask a crew member, a past customer or a friend in each town you want to sell in to search “pool builder” and “inground pool” on their phone and send you a screenshot of the map. In our judgement, three or four towns are enough to see the pattern: if the competitor beats you everywhere, it’s more than distance; if they only beat you near their own office, distance explains most of it.

Is their office simply closer to the homeowners searching?

Often, yes. Distance isn’t something a profile edit can change. Google’s guidelines say a profile represents your real-world location: you can’t list a virtual office or a rented mailing address, and service-area businesses should have one profile for the central office with a designated service area. Source: Guidelines for representing your business on Google.

That has a practical consequence. If a competitor’s office sits in the middle of the suburb where most new pools are going in and yours is two towns over, they’ll tend to win searches in that suburb, and listing it as a service area won’t cancel the distance. In our judgement, the honest options are to win the towns near you outright, to earn enough reviews and links that prominence carries you farther, and to use ads for the suburbs that matter but sit outside your natural reach. How to set the areas up correctly is in setting up your service area.

Does their profile match pool searches better than mine?

Relevance is where profiles differ most and where you have the most control. Google says businesses with complete and accurate information are more likely to show up in local results, and that incomplete information can keep a profile from showing up for relevant searches in your area. Source: Tips to improve your local ranking on Google.

Put the two profiles side by side and compare:

• Category. The label under their name hints at their primary category. If they read as a pool contractor and you read as something broader, that’s a gap.
• Services. Do they list new construction, fiberglass, renovation and resurfacing while yours lists two generic services?
• Hours, description and photos. Are theirs filled in and recent while yours are blank or years old?

If your category is the weak point, the fix is in choosing the right categories. Don’t copy a competitor’s categories that aren’t true for you; Google’s guidelines say not to use categories as keywords.

Do they have more reviews or a better rating?

Reviews feed prominence, and Google says more reviews and positive ratings can help your local ranking. Source: Tips to improve your local ranking on Google. Google shows the review score, top reviews and total number of reviews on Search and Maps. The score is the average of all ratings published on Google for that business, on a scale of 1 to 5 stars, and it can take up to 2 weeks to update after a new review. Source: Understand review scores for local places & businesses.

Compare three things: the total count, the average, and, in our judgement, how recent the latest reviews are and whether the owner replies. A builder with three times your reviews has a head start that takes seasons to close, because pool companies finish far fewer jobs a year than service trades. The fix is a steady system that asks every customer, covered in getting more Google reviews. If a few bad reviews are dragging your average down, see responding to negative reviews.

Do more websites mention and link to them?

Google says prominence is also based on information like how many websites link to your business. Source: Tips to improve your local ranking on Google. You can’t see a competitor’s link count from Maps, but you can see the kind of company that earns links: one that’s listed in a manufacturer’s dealer locator, belongs to a builders’ association, shows up in home show listings, or had a backyard featured in the local paper.

In our judgement, a builder that’s been around for decades often wins here simply because the web has had more time to mention it. Paying for links is a shortcut we’d avoid. What you can do is make sure every legitimate place you belong to actually lists and links to you, and that your website gives other sites a reason to link: project galleries, clear service pages, and the towns you build in.

Is their business name stuffed with keywords?

Sometimes the builder above you is called something like “Best Inground Pools Springfield” on Google while its trucks say something shorter. Google’s guidelines say your name should match your real-world name as used on your storefront, website and stationery, and that adding unnecessary information to it isn’t permitted and could get the profile suspended. That includes service or product information and location information. Source: Guidelines for representing your business on Google.

Don’t copy it. Renaming your profile to add “Pools” and a city puts your own profile at risk of suspension. If the name is genuinely the company’s legal and real-world name, there’s nothing wrong with it, and it’s simply a name you’ll compete against. If it isn’t, the next section covers what you can do.

Should I report a competitor I think is breaking the rules?

Only when there’s a real rule break, not because they rank above you. Google gives owners and users several routes. Source: Report a business on Google Maps.

• Wrong information that isn’t a policy issue: use Suggest an edit on the listing.
• Misleading names, phone numbers or websites that suggest fraud: Google points to its Business Redressal Complaint form.
• A business that pays or pressures people for reviews: Google says reviews in exchange for a payment, deal or discount are prohibited, and you can report the business’s conduct from the Maps app.

In our judgement, keep the report factual, with evidence such as a photo of their real signage, then get back to your own profile; that work pays off whether or not Google acts.

Could something be wrong with my own profile?

Before you blame the competitor, rule out your own side. Google says verifying your business makes it more likely to show up in search results, and that complete, accurate information helps. Source: Tips to improve your local ranking on Google. Check that your profile is verified, that your category, hours and service areas are what you set, and that Google hasn’t changed anything without your notice.

Also check for review restrictions. Google says that when it finds a business has broken its fake engagement policy, it may stop the profile from receiving new reviews for a set period, unpublish existing reviews for a set period or show a warning that fake reviews were removed, and it notifies the owner by email. Source: Business Profile restrictions for policy violations. If a former marketer bought reviews on your behalf, that could be the reason, and the appeal route is on the same page.

Which gap should I work on first?

Once you’ve compared the two profiles, work through the gaps in this order, which is our recommendation, not a Google rule:

1. Check for ads. If the spot is paid, decide whether to bid, and stop comparing profiles.
2. Search from their town. If they only win near their own office, accept the distance and focus on your side.
3. Compare category and services. These are the fastest fixes on your side.
4. Compare reviews. Start the system now; it compounds over seasons.
5. Compare website and links. The slowest gap to close, so start early.

Then watch the Searches numbers in your Performance report, which show the terms people used to find your profile, and the calls and website clicks it produced. Google notes the numbers include activity from both organic results and Google Ads. Source: Understand your Business Profile performance & insights. Moving up only matters if it brings consultations, so follow those calls through to signed contracts with tracking signed pool contracts.

What's different when a pool builder is outranked

The competitor may not be a builder. In our experience, a search for “pool” plus a town often shows service companies and supply stores too. A service company with hundreds of route customers can collect reviews much faster than you, so judge yourself against the builders that show for build searches like “inground pool builder”, not every pool business on the map.

Review counts move slowly. A builder finishes far fewer jobs a year than a service trade, so a review gap takes seasons, not weeks, to close. Start before spring.

Showroom versus service area. A competitor with a staffed design center can show its address; a builder who works from a yard can’t. That changes how the map displays both of you, not the rules each must follow.

A worked example: comparing two pool builders side by side

These numbers are made up to show the reasoning, not a benchmark. You build about 25 pools a year from an office on the east side of the county. A competitor shows above you in Maps on your phone. Here’s what the side-by-side check finds:

• Ads: no ad label on their listing, so it’s organic.
• Distance: friends in four towns send screenshots. You win the two towns nearest your office; they win the two nearest theirs.
• Category and services: both of you read as pool contractors, but they list 14 services and you list 3.
• Reviews: they have 140 reviews at 4.6 stars; you have 45 at 4.9.
• Website: theirs has a page for every pool type and a large gallery; yours has a homepage and a contact form.

The conclusion: distance explains the towns near their office, and you can’t change that in Maps. But they have about three times your reviews, a fuller services list and a deeper website. Adding services is a one-afternoon job. The review gap is the long one: if you ask every customer and two out of three leave a review, that’s about 17 new reviews a year, so closing a gap of 95 reviews would take years, not a season. That’s the honest reason to pair the profile work with ads for the two towns near them.

Frequently asked questions

Can I pay Google to move above my competitor in Maps?

Not in the organic results. Google says there’s no way to request or pay for a better local ranking. You can pay for an ad, which is labeled as one. Source: Tips to improve your local ranking on Google.

My competitor has fewer reviews but still ranks higher. Why?

Reviews are only part of prominence, and prominence is one of three factors. A closer office or a profile that matches the search better can outweigh a review lead.

Can I see which keywords my competitor ranks for in Maps?

Your own Performance report shows the terms people used to find your profile. For a competitor, searching from several towns and noting where they appear is the practical check.

Why does the competitor rank above me in one town but not another?

Distance. Google weighs how far each business is from the person searching, so the order changes as the searcher moves. That pattern usually points to office location, not a weak profile.

Should I open a second office address to rank in their area?

Only if it’s a real, staffed location. Google’s guidelines don’t allow virtual offices or rented mailing addresses, and a profile built on one risks suspension.

Key takeaways

• Google ranks local results mainly on relevance, distance and how well known you are; nobody can pay for organic rank.
• Rule out ads first: a labeled ad above you is a budget question, not a profile problem.
• Search from your customers’ towns; distance explains many gaps you can’t fix in Maps.
• Compare category, services, reviews and links side by side to find the gap you can close.
• Report competitors only for genuine rule breaks, and never copy a keyword-stuffed name.

More in this section

• How do I get my pool company to rank in Google Maps?
• How do I optimize a pool builder Google Business Profile?
• How should a pool builder set up its Google service area?
• How do I get more Google reviews for my pool company?
• How does a pool builder show up in AI search results?

Sources

1. Tips to improve your local ranking on Google — Google Business Profile Help
2. Automatically generating and ranking results — Google Search: How Search Works
3. About location assets — Google Ads Help
4. Guidelines for representing your business on Google — Google Business Profile Help
5. Understand review scores for local places & businesses — Google Business Profile Help
6. Report a business on Google Maps — Google Maps Help
7. Business Profile restrictions for policy violations — Google Business Profile Help
8. Understand your Business Profile performance & insights — Google Business Profile Help